They came like machine gun fire today…okay, that’s a little over-the-top. There were two right in a row, so i guess that doesn’t qualify as machine gun-like. It was rapid fire, though. 47 seconds apart, according to email time stamps.
It’s not a big surprise that the rejections were close together because they were both from the same magazine. One Story told me, “unfortunately, we feel your story doesn’t fit with One Story.” And then told me the same thing 47 seconds later.
You can’t even open two emails and their attachments that quickly, nonetheless read a story and respond to it. So I see two possibilities. I’m not sure which I dislike more…
The first possibility is that there was a list of stories to review, so the editors got together, made their final selection, as One Story is precisely that…One story at a time makes up the whole issue, and then emailed everyone else that didn’t make that final cut all in one sitting.
The second possibility is that they saw my submission, didn’t recognize the name as anyone noteworthy in the literary world and sent me the cut and paste or autoresponse.
I don’t like the first possibility becuase it means I didn’t make the grade.
I don’t like the second possibility because I didn’t even get a chance.
My first response is to think the second possibility is better, not having been rejected on my actual work, but solely because my name is not yet marketable, but the more I think about that, the more I tend to think the second possibility is much worse.
No, I am positive the second possibility is worse.
It would be worlds better to have an editor write back, telling me how he really didn’t like what I wrote, why it sucked, what needs his magazine has that I failed to meet, all the problems he saw with what I wrote than to just have my stuff thrown out.
This initial response, thinking it might be better not to have been rejected based on my work, is almost the exact cowardice that kept me from sending any stories out to publishers for years. I could come up with a million reasons back then why it wasn’t time yet. Didn’t have enough stories. Didn’t have a plan. Didn’t have my “voice” yet. Didn’t know how it all worked yet. Didn’t think this story or that story was polished enough….
And I believed every one of them.
I can’t speak for everyone who writes, but I know for me, it’s a real roller coaster of confidence. I’ll finish a story, read it through and think it’s a good strong piece that I am proud to have my name attached to. I’ll read it and know it has a real shot at being published.
Then, my confidence will roll over the top of that hill and start its way down. I’ll try to explain a story to someone and hear my own verbal explanation of the story and think, Wow, that really sounds awful when I explain it like that. I’ll start to think of the sheer volume of people trying to get published out there and start to wonder what exactly makes me think my stuff should stand out or what keeps my stuff from just being run of the mill. I’ll read a fantastic short story and think Now that’s how it’s done.
But then i’ll pick up some literary magazine or even a book and run across something I feel really is run of the mill. That’s when I start up the next hill. At the risk of sounding cocky, I have to admit, I’ve read published material and thought If this got published I know my stuff is good enough. Sometimes all it takes is just to re-read one of my stories to boost my confidence again.
As time goes by, despite the rejections, I have more ups than downs in my confidence level. More and more, the downs are just becoming moments of doubt that are fleeting. I think i’ll need to find a new analogy to replace my roller coaster one. it’s a pretty boring roller coaster that spends most of its time going uphill.